Weighing Your Options: First Home Buyer Schemes vs. Property Investments in NSW

Deciding between capitalising on first home buyer schemes in New South Wales (NSW) or investing in a rental property presents a multifaceted decision. Each pathway offers distinct benefits and challenges, each contingent on your individual financial circumstances, long-term objectives, and lifestyle preferences.

Understanding First Home Buyer Schemes in NSW


  • Government Incentives
    Through the First Home Owner Grant (FHOG) and the First Home Buyers Assistance Scheme, eligible buyers may significantly reduce their upfront expenses.
  • Wealth Accumulation
    Purchasing your first home is a stepping stone towards building personal wealth, creating equity, and potential capital growth in the long run.
  • Stability and Personal Freedom
    Home ownership provides stability and the flexibility to customise your living space. Furthermore, your main residence is usually exempt from capital gains tax, as long as you reside in the property.


  • Constraints on Property Type and Value
    The FHOG and stamp duty concessions have restrictions on the property's type and value (new homes only for the FHOG).
  • Residency Requirements
    To qualify for first home buyer incentives, you need to live in the property as your principal residence for a specified period (typically six continuous months within the first year).

Delving into Property Investments

  • Rental Income
    Owning an investment property allows for a consistent stream of rental income, helping to offset mortgage payments and other related expenses.
  • Flexibility of Location
    As an investor, you have the freedom to invest in areas you believe will experience strong capital growth, while choosing to rent in an area that better fits your lifestyle preferences. This dual-benefit strategy isn't usually available to owner-occupiers.
  • Tax Deductions 
    Expenses related to the property, such as loan interest, property maintenance, and depreciation, can often be deducted from taxable income.
  • Potential Capital Growth
    Over time, your property may appreciate in value. Unlike homeowner-occupiers, as an investor, you can strategically decide when to sell to maximise capital gains.


  • Lack of Government Incentives
    Unlike first home buyers, property investors aren't eligible for benefits like the FHOG or stamp duty concessions.
  • Incurred Expenses
    Property investors need to account for additional costs, including property management fees, vacancy periods, and maintenance expenses.
  • Market Volatility
    Rental market conditions and property values may fluctuate, which could affect your investment returns.
  • Capital Gains Tax
    Usually, selling an investment property incurs capital gains tax, although some concessions might be available depending on your ownership duration.


The decision to utilise first home buyer schemes or to invest in a rental property in NSW largely depends on your personal financial situation, aspirations, and lifestyle choices. It's essential to seek advice from financial planners, mortgage brokers, and property experts to make an informed decision that best aligns with your unique situation.


What to read next?

Cost of Living Impact on Rental Demand

In June, the average rental price for houses in Sydney was $1,040 per week, down 1.4% from last month but up 7.0% over the past 12 months.

Read more

Navigating Seasonal Shifts and Policy Impacts

May has been a quieter month for the rental market, with 34 properties leased by the Chidiac team across Sydney (compared to 39 in April...

Read more

Safeguarding your investment: The importance of Landlord Insurance

Landlord insurance offers crucial protection for property owners who rent out their properties, covering various risks such as accidental...

Read more

Ensure Your Property's Safety: Smoke Alarm Compliance

As a property owner or manager, ensuring the safety of your tenants and compliance with state regulations is crucial.

Read more